A potential federal class-action lawsuit alleges that there is a long-standing practice of excessive force at Sacramento's Main Jail. Robert Hunter, a 52-year-old veterinarian filed the lawsuit. He was arrested on suspicion of drunken driving early Sept. 17 and spent the night in the Main Jail. While there, his suit claims, three deputies threw him to the floor and fractured his elbow when he tried to signal them that the holding cell's toilet was clogged and overflowing. Shortly afterward, according to the suit, Hunter spoke up for another inmate being similarly handled and a deputy told him to "shut up, weasel, and keep facing the wall."
A Sheriff's Lieutenant noted that Hunter did not file a formal complaint with the department until many months later. "The complaint will be fully and fairly investigated, without bias, and if any deficiencies are found, appropriate action will be taken," he said. The lawsuit states that Hunter "requested medical treatment and was denied such treatment." Hunter said in an interview that he was afraid to press the deputies for medical attention after he was denied.
Hunter's complaint was filed March 3 in U.S. District Court in Sacramento. A second plaintiff in the Hunter case, Howard Eley, claims he was choked and slapped by a deputy in the Main Jail on March 21, 2004. The deputy involved was fired by the sheriff after other officers brought the incident to their supervisors' attention.
Class-action lawsuits based on claims of excessive force are difficult because the cases are so individualized," Hunter's attorney said. "In excessive force cases, each case is generally judged on its own."