Attorneys for the Van Buren School District in Arkansas recently argued that a judge's decision granting class action status in a lawsuit against the Van Buren School District should be overturned because there is no way to determine who would be in the class. The lawsuit was filed by former Van Buren teacher Steve Jones in 2003, claiming he was not compensated for some required non-instructional duty.
A Crawford County circuit judge certified Jones' suit as a class action last May, permitting as many as 500 Van Buren teachers to join the litigation. Jones' attorney, said members of the class could be identified through "duty sheets" that list when teachers had "duty" monitoring students before or after school, or during lunch.
Jones was fired by Superintendent Merle Dickerson for failing to attend a faculty meeting in 2005 and for leaving one early in January. The Van Buren School Board upheld the termination. There's no question he was fired in retaliation for exercising his First Amendment rights," his attorney said. Jones claims the district breached his contract by requiring him to sometimes be at work for "morning duty" at 7:15 a.m., or by not allowing a duty-free lunch. He also seeks compensation for extra days he said he worked as a coach.
The district claims the time Jones seeks pay for is considered part of a "day" in his teacher contract.
Attorneys contended that the only way to determine who might be owed additional money is to interview teachers individually to determine how many minutes pay they would be entitled.
"If there are teachers working non-instructional work, there is no data, there is no record, there is no way to determine who worked non-instructional time," Jones' attorney said.
Circuit Judge Mike Medlock defined the class last year as any teacher employed by the Van Buren district since August 1998 who performed uncompensated, non-instructional duties.
His attorneys claim class-action status opens the district to a liability of up to $750,000.