A nationwide class action has been filed against insurance companies Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc., Aon Corporation and its affiliates, and the Willis Group, on behalf of all persons who directly or indirectly engaged the defendants’ insurance brokerage services between August 26, 1994, and the present. The action alleges that the companies have conspired to fraudulently conceal that they have entered into placement service agreements with third-party insurance companies which pay them additional fees based on such factors as profitability, growth, and the volume of insurance the defendants place with the participating insurers, in violation of the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act. The action seeks unspecified compensatory and triple punitive damages.
The action alleges that, under the brokers’ marketing scheme, they hold themselves out to the public as experts in the analysis and procurement of insurance to meet customers’ insurance needs. As brokers, the defendants’ first priority is to find for their customers the best coverage at the lowest cost. It is with the promise of unbiased brokerage advice that customers engage the defendants’ services, unaware that the defendants allegedly have previously-made agreements with certain insurers-- agreements that influence the brokers to steer customers to purchase coverage with those particular insurers, regardless of what is best for the customer.
By steering customers to purchase insurance coverage with only those insurers with whom the defendants have placement service agreements, the brokers reap substantial additional fees-- all the while purporting to provide independent and unbiased brokerage advice. The lawsuit alleges that the brokers have actually entered into a conspiracy with other insurance brokerage firms, insurers and their affiliates, industry trade associations, and other entities to assure the secrecy and longevity of their profit-making racketeering.
On January 31, 2005, a settlement was announced between Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc. and the New York Attorney General's Office and the New York Superintendent of Insurance. Marsh has agreed to create a restitution fund of $850 million for its domestic policyholder clients.
The action implicates the following companies as primary conspirators:
• Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc.
• Marsh, Inc.
• Marsh USA, Inc.
• AON Corporation
• AON Brokers Services, Inc.
• AON Risk Services Companies, Inc.
• AON Risk Services, Inc., U.S.
• Aon Group, Inc.
• AON Services Group, Inc.
• Willis Group Holdings, Ltd.
• Willis Group, Ltd.
• Willis North America, Inc.
The 38-page complaint lays out an intricate conspiracy that allegedly allowed the defendants to make hundreds of millions of dollars in additional fees by subverting their clients’ best interests.