The parties have reached a tentative $7,337,500 settlement in an action filed against HA-LO Industries, Inc. and certain of its officers and directors by stockholders who purchased the company's common stock between February 18, 1999, and July 30, 2001. Persons eligible to take part in the settlement must submit a proof of claim form postmarked no later than December 31, 2004, to be eligible for a portion of the settlement.
Prior to its declaration of bankruptcy in 2001, HA-LO was engaged in the promotional products and direct marketing businesses. The lawsuit claimed that certain HA-LO officers and directors misled investors: (1) by intentionally overstating revenues and income that the company earned from its direct marketing business; (2) regarding alleged problems with HA-LO’s acquisition of Starbelly, Inc.; and (3) regarding the alleged likelihood of HA-LO’s filing for bankruptcy. The lawsuit also claimed that HA-LO issued press releases and financial statements in which it disseminated false and misleading information about the company’s income and earnings during the applicable period.
Pursuant to the settlement, the defendants are assigning to the plaintiffs their rights to pursue claims against those insurance carriers that provide coverage for the claims asserted. Claims against these carriers have already resulted in $7,337,500 to be made available to the class. This amount may be increased by recovery from the last remaining carrier, Zurich American Insurance Company, but this additional recovery is not guaranteed-- until all claims are resolved, plaintiffs’ counsel cannot say how much will be finally available for distribution to the class.
Once the amount of the settlement fund is established, each class member’s actual recovery will be a proportion of the net settlement fund determined by their claim as compared to the total claims of all class members who submit valid proofs of claim. Based on consultations with damages experts, the plaintiffs estimate that there were approximately 190 million shares of HA-LO common stock traded during the class period that may have been damaged. Based on the $7,337,500 recovered to date, plaintiffs estimate that the average recovery per damaged share of HA-LO common stock under the settlement is $0.04 per share before deduction of court-awarded attorneys’ fees and expenses.
The claim formula is the basis upon which the net settlement fund will be proportionately allocated to authorized claimants. For each claimant, the recognized claim is
the product of the number of shares of HA-LO bought multiplied by the following multiplier, depending on the date the shares were purchased:
Shares Purchased-on Date Multiplier:
2/18/99-7/1/99 $ 3.557
7/2/99-12/7/99 $ 1.705
12/8/99-1/4/00 $ 2.799
1/5/00-7/24/00 $ 5.176
7/27/00-10/24/00 $ 3.476
10/25/00-2/15/01 $ 2.966
2/16/01-7/27/01 $ 0.718
Thus, if a claimant bought 3,000 shares of HA-LO on December 15, 1999, and 4,000 shares of HA-LO on October 22, 2000, that member’s recognized claim = (3,000 x $2.799)+(4,000 x $3.476)=$22,301. The recognized claim formula is not intended to be an estimate of the amount of what a class member might have been able to recover after a trial; nor is it an estimate of the amount that will be paid to claimants pursuant to the settlement.
For more information about the settlement, you can call 1-800-447-7657 toll free; or write to:
HA-LO Settlement
Gilardi & Co., LLC
P.O. Box 8040
San Rafael, CA
94912-8040
The settlement will not be effective until the court grants it final approval. The court has scheduled a hearing on the matter for October 1, 2004.